Why your email marketing bill went up: subscriber counting rules at Mailchimp, MailerLite and Kit
We have not hands-on tested these; this compares official documentation. Some links may become affiliate links in future; we currently have no affiliate relationships. Disclosure
The question: Your list didn't feel bigger, but the bill jumped. Which people are you paying for, and when does the count reset?
Short answer
Each platform defines a billable person differently. Mailchimp counts subscribed, unsubscribed and non-subscribed contacts in your audiences (archived, cleaned and deleted ones are excluded). MailerLite counts only active subscribers, but anyone active at any point in the billing cycle counts until the cycle resets. Kit says subscribers are counted only if they are unique and active.
Comparison table (official sources)
| Rule | Mailchimp | MailerLite | Kit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unsubscribed people | Counted (until archived or deleted) | Not counted | Not counted (only active subscribers) |
| Bounced / cleaned | Cleaned contacts not counted | Bounced not counted | Not stated on pricing page |
| Deleting mid-cycle | Reduce audience and keep the lower total for a full billing cycle to avoid future additional charges | Still counts until the billing anniversary reset | Not stated on pricing page |
| Going over your tier (paid) | Service continues; additional charge appears on the bill | Tier increases automatically; card charged for next tier | Not stated on pricing page |
| Send limits (paid) | Essentials: 10x contact limit; Standard: 12x; Premium: 15x | Comfort: 10x the top of your subscriber tier; Power: unlimited (fair use) | Unlimited broadcasts listed |
| Do test emails count? | Yes, test and transactional emails count toward the monthly sending limit | A send = one email to one subscriber | Not stated |
Who should pick which
- If you collect many one-time buyers check how unsubscribes are counted. On Mailchimp you need to archive unsubscribed contacts for them to stop counting.
- If your list churns a lot MailerLite's cumulative-per-cycle rule means cleanup only lowers the count after the next billing anniversary.
- If you want the simplest rule Kit's 'unique and active' definition is the shortest, but its over-limit behaviour was not stated on the page we read.
Official sites: Mailchimp, MailerLite, Kit.
Check before you buy
- Export your list and count statuses before choosing a tier.
- Schedule list cleanup a few days before your billing date, not after it.
- Read the current pricing page on the day you subscribe; tiers change.
What we could not verify
- We did not log in to any account; in-app billing screens may show more detail.
- Kit's bounce handling and overage rule were not stated on its pricing page.
- 2027 Social Media Content Calendar for Small Shops (Excel) — 365-day planner, content pillars and idea bank.
Sources
- Mailchimp: About Mailchimp pricing plans
https://mailchimp.com/help/about-mailchimp-pricing-plans/ - MailerLite pricing FAQ
https://www.mailerlite.com/pricing - Kit pricing
https://kit.com/pricing