Printful vs Printify: is the paid plan worth it for a small print-on-demand shop?
We have not hands-on tested these; this compares official documentation. Some links may become affiliate links in future; we currently have no affiliate relationships. Disclosure
The question: Both let you start free. When does paying for Printful Growth or Printify Premium start to make sense?
Short answer
Both start at $0. Printful's paid plan is $24.99/month and becomes free when you reach $12K/year in sales; it advertises up to 33% off products. Printify's paid plan is from $39/month, or from $24.99/month billed yearly, with up to 20% off all products (and a 33% figure shown for new products).
Comparison table (official sources)
| Printful | Printify | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Yes, $0/month | Yes, $0/month |
| Paid plan price | $24.99/month; free when you reach $12K/year in sales | From $39/month, or from $24.99/month billed yearly (36% saving stated) |
| Discount on paid plan | Up to 33% on products | Up to 20% on all products; up to 33% on new products |
| Production model | In-house production with a 3-step quality check | Marketplace of 70+ print providers, 2,000+ products |
| Error policy stated | Free reprint or refund if a manufacturing error occurs | Not stated on pricing page |
| Free trial of paid plan | Yes ('we'll remind you before your free trial ends') | Not stated on pricing page |
Who should pick which
- Stay free on either if you are still testing designs; the paid plans only pay off once discounts on your monthly volume exceed the fee.
- Consider Printful if you value a single in-house producer and the stated reprint/refund policy, or you are near $12K/year (when Growth becomes free).
- Consider Printify if you want to choose among many print providers and are willing to pay yearly.
Official sites: Printful, Printify.
Check before you buy
- Break-even: if your monthly product cost is C and the discount is d, the plan pays when C x d is above the plan fee (e.g. $24.99 / 20% means about $125/month in base cost).
- Shipping, taxes and storefront fees are not included in product discounts.
- Discount percentages are 'up to'; your products may get less.
What we could not verify
- We did not compare base product prices or print quality.
- Printify's trial terms and error policy were not on the pricing page.
Our own product (disclosure: we make and sell this on Gumroad):
- Product Pricing Workbook (Excel) — Materials, labour, margin, wholesale and sale discounts.
- Marketplace Fee & True Profit Calculator (Excel) — Etsy, Shopify, Amazon, Gumroad and eBay fees in one workbook.
Sources
- Printful pricing
https://www.printful.com/pricing - Printify pricing
https://printify.com/pricing/