Pirate Ship vs Shippo vs ShipStation: shipping label software costs for a small US shop
We have not hands-on tested these; this compares official documentation. Some links may become affiliate links in future; we currently have no affiliate relationships. Disclosure
The question: You ship a few dozen to a few hundred parcels a month. Do you need to pay for label software at all?
Short answer
Pirate Ship states no monthly fees, no payment fees and no markup. Shippo has a free Starter plan for up to 30 labels a month (5 cents per label if you connect your own carrier account) and Pro from $17/month. ShipStation starts at $14.99/month for 50 shipments with a 30-day free trial.
Comparison table (official sources)
| Pirate Ship | Shippo | ShipStation | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free option | Yes; 'No monthly fees, payment fees, or hidden costs' | Starter: free, up to 30 labels/month | 30-day free trial, no card required |
| Entry paid price | None | Pro from $17/month (1-200 labels) or $205/year | Starter $14.99/month (50 shipments) |
| Next steps up | n/a | Pro tiers up to 10,000 labels; $0.08/label beyond 10,000 | Starter 100/mo $29.99, 500/mo $39.99, 1,000/mo $79.99 |
| Own carrier account | Not stated on the pages we read | 5 cents/label on Starter; free on Pro | Bring existing carrier accounts on Standard and up |
| Carriers named on page | USPS and UPS | USPS, UPS, FedEx, DHL Express | 'Every major carrier' |
| Users | Not stated | Starter 1, Pro up to 5 | Starter 3 users, Standard 10 users |
Who should pick which
- Pick Pirate Ship if you ship USPS/UPS from the US and want no subscription at all.
- Pick Shippo if you ship under 30 labels a month and want multiple carriers on a free plan, or you need branded tracking pages on Pro.
- Pick ShipStation if you have multiple sales channels, need automations or several users, and can justify a monthly fee.
Official sites: Shippo, ShipStation, Pirate Ship.
Check before you buy
- All three are US-focused; check whether they support your origin country.
- Discount claims (e.g. 'up to 89%', '80-90%') are the vendors' own marketing statements; actual savings depend on parcel and route.
- Postage itself is extra in every case.
What we could not verify
- Pirate Ship's user-seat limits and international carrier list were not stated on the page we read.
- We did not compare actual label rates.
Our own product (disclosure: we make and sell this on Gumroad):
- Marketplace Fee & True Profit Calculator (Excel) — Etsy, Shopify, Amazon, Gumroad and eBay fees in one workbook.
Sources
- Pirate Ship
https://www.pirateship.com/ - Shippo pricing
https://goshippo.com/pricing - ShipStation pricing
https://www.shipstation.com/pricing/